Сообщение от M3ls
Хороший разбор "дриблинга" Дембеле от одного пользователя с barcaforum.
Too right. He's mostly isolated from build up play. The pro-Dembele faction claims that other players don't like Dembele or rather there's a "veteran clique" in Barcelona. I say Dembele's tactical understanding is quite lacking, leading him to be in poor positions relative to the current build up leading the others to take the better choices. He struggles with quick short passing, in a team whose playstyle is based off quick short passing (or used to be). He struggles with controlling the ball in tight areas. He struggles with first touches in tight areas. He has poor spatial awareness, often not being aware of an incoming press leading him not to position his body to shield the ball - making him an easy target for dispossession. His decision making is very poor, often when he has the time and/or space he makes the worst decisions; it's when he's on autopilot that he seems to make his best plays. Unfortunately that "autopilot mode" comes way too infrequently.
His dribbling is a bit weird. His dribbling is based on his absurd acceleration, his ambidexterity, and his decent balance in high speeds; leading him to easily swift side to side when he's on his stride (accelerating with the ball) quite easily - it's unpredictable for defenders. He however doesn't possess a control over his center of gravity like shorter players do, nor does he have the agility and footwork of "tall" wingers like Neymar, Sancho, Sanй, Cr7, and so on. His footwork, his ability to drop his shoulder, and sense of balance while not in stride are laughably poor. It's a prime reason why he's terrible in tight spaces, because tight spaces negate what makes his dribbling so impressive. It's also why when he's stationary, he's a remarkably poor dribbler that struggles on 1 vs 1s. Despite having such an unbalanced skillset for dribbling, his is still enough to put him among Europe's elite (who else can dribble 10 times in a single match? Not a lot of players). However in a team like Barcelona, tight spaces matter; not high speed of play where his dribbling strength lies in.
I saw some creativity and playmaking in Dortmund, but here it's non-existent. I can count two or so games from this season where he displayed at the very least decent playmaking abilities.
His finishing is another weird area. I actually think he has an insane technique for finishing. The PSV, Spur, Sevilla, Villarreal, Celta Vigo, and Espanyol goals from this and last season are clear examples of elite technique in finishing. I just don't think however, that he has the tools to utilise his inherent technique. Whether it's composure, peripheral vision to check goalkeeper's position, creativity, and decision making - he's so lacking in these areas that it leads him to make some atrocious attempts, the Liverpool misses are prime examples of it. Statistically he overperformed this season/was lucky: just look at the Sevilla brace, the several games streak where he got goals of deflections and scuff shots in the beginning of the season are examples of goals that inflated his stats. He scored about 8 "real" goals this season: real goals being goals based on solid movement and confident finishing.
Overall I just don't think he's fit for the club. You can say he's young and he can improve, but considering he plays the same way he did since his debut...I'm confident this is the player he's going to be. A solid 10-12~ goals winger, some runs of very good games, but also a lot of mediocrity and inconsistency during the season. Paying 140m euros and being a symbol of the "Post Messi era", I at the very least expect a Hazard level talent.
|
